Skip to main content

Self Portraits of Sex Workers in India

Nothing tellsthe truth like self portaits. One of the sex workers participating in this project said, "My hands shivered when I held a camera for the first time. Now I can go back to the village swirling the camera on my finger." 

The Me by Me project is a UNDP initiative that conducted capacity building workshops in pictorial documentation to sex workers (male and female) and their children. 

The reality of sex workers is often documented from the perspective of project planners and implementers. They are yet to move beyond the box of being recipients of ‘welfare schemes’ and ‘health education’. They are also relentlessly part of debates about the ‘rightness’ of their existence. 



In all this, their realities often get muddied in theories and moral discourses.

I devised a 41 day project in 2007 in which 426 sex workers from 16 districts in 6 Indian states participated,  The project was supported by 7 trainers, 46 individuals from 34 NGOs and 13 UNDP-TAHA team members. 

Me by Me was covered in 31 electronic and print media.

Me by Me workshops were conducted in 16 districts within six states of India. These are listed below:

  1. Andhra Pradesh: Warangal, Guntur, Vijaywada, Vishakapatnam
  2. Uttar Pradesh: Kanpur, Lucknow, Varanasi
  3. Gujarat: Rajkot, Ahmedabad, Baroda
  4. Orissa: Angul, Bhubaneswar
  5. Bihar; Muzaffarpur
  6. West Bengal: Calcutta, Siliguri, Shantipur

A total of seven trainers were chosen to conduct the workshops on the basis of their previous work experience, fluency in the local language, availability of coinciding dates, and comfort level with working in the target community. Trainers were provided with a 4 day training syllabus that they then used as a guideline to formulate their own training modules. They were remunerated based on the number of days they worked on the project.

At the state level, the Me by Me project received administrative assistance from the TAHA SPMU staff and the SACS. The SPMU personnel, in collaboration with the NGOs involved, contacted participants, organized the venue, drafted a budget for expenses and organized accommodation and transport for all those involved in the project. In addition, coordinators from the TAHA secretariat in Delhi were allocated to facilitate the training workshops in some states.

The workshops included some basic theory of photography (light, colour, image, reflection, shadow, distance) and how to use a camera most effectively. The importance of photo-documentation and the various uses of photographs were discussed at length. Participants gave examples of how the camera will come in handy as an advocacy tool for them. They were taught basic techniques of photography and were given photography assignments during the training. The photographs they took were discussed at length with the trainer- what they liked/ didn’t like, common mistakes, execution of ideas, and so on. Photographs from each participant were chosen for the exhibition on the last day. A VIP and the press were invited for this. The reviews received from the media were evidence of how this training has been successful in improved advocacy for the sex workers community. Below are a few excerpts from press reviews and some quotes from the participants.

Press reviews: Me by Me in the News

Right from the horses mouth. That’s what UNDP’s Me by Me is all about. Sex workers shall tell their own stories through pictorial documentation of their moment to moment struggle for life and minute to minute battle against indignity, rejection and discrimination.
- Hindustan Times, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, 9th of February, 2007.

Take me as I am” seemed to be what each photograph at this exhibition held at Hotel Hindustan International today wanted to convey.

“Only someone like me can understand the life I lead. I live two lives ~ that of a normal man at home and a woman in my community of people with similar orientations. These photographs have helped me come out of the closet,” said Rajkumar Das, a transgender sex-worker and a Plus member. 
- Calcutta Plus, 20th of February, 2007.

Sex workers from Muzafarpur participated in the Me by Me workshop that has culminated in an exhibition being held here. The photographs are a reflection of the participants own interests and concerns.
- Rashtriya Sahara, Patna, 28th of February, 2007.

Participants’ quotes:

"In every area everybody is discriminating sex workers. They don’t give houses for rent to them. Now we can take photos the housing situations, and give a memorandum to the Government Officials like District Collector"

"When I clicked my first photo, I saw the flash. That was the happiest moment. I am really excited. Now I am also a photographer"

"Nobody believes when we say our problems. Now we show our problems through photos. Definitely they will believe."

"What the Resource Person taught us, fixed in our minds as a film role fixes in a camera"

"We can’t forget what we learn here as we cannot forget the smell of earth as the first rain drop falls on earth."

"We have a severe eve teasing problem in our areas. Now we can fight against them with photo evidences. Some times the police also don’t trust us even if we say that we are Peer Educators. They take us to police station by force. Now we take pictures of those situations"

"I am illiterate – I have not been able to take notes but I have them memorized by heart."

"We can earn money by taking photos in our NGO’s programs like AASHA campaign. From here onwards we will be the photographers in our NGOs"

"Usually in the hospitals, the medical staff ill-treats us. Now we take photos of those situations to give complaints against them."

"Photography will help us to tell about our lives, families, sorrows, happiness things to the world. Now we are able to tell the Government about our problems with photo evidences"



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why call a blog by this name? 'Army of Lovers' ?

"Love," said Phaedrus, "is the oldest of Gods, and one of the most powerful. Give me an Army made up of lovers and I can conquer the world." The  Phaedrus  ( / ˈ f iː d r ə s / ;  Greek :  Φαῖδρος ), written by  Plato , is a dialogue between Plato's main  protagonist ,  Socrates , and  Phaedrus , an interlocutor in  several dialogues . The  Phaedrus  was presumably composed around 370 BC, around the same time as Plato's Republic  and  Symposium .   Although ostensibly about the topic of  love , the discussion in the dialogue revolves around the art of  rhetoric  and how it should be practiced, and dwells on subjects as diverse as  metempsychosis  (the Greek tradition of  reincarnation ) and  erotic love .

A Debate That Is Breaking Up The Women's Movement Everywhere

Notions of sexual morality and decency can be divisive externalities in an otherwise value driven discussion on human rights.  Here is how. AmnestyInternational 's  call for decriminalisation of sexwork has yet again pried open the divisions between the women’s empowerment movements around the world. Abolitionists have long argued that sexwork is not only demeaning for women in and of itself, but worse, it leads to trafficking of women and girls and hence should be abolished. Sexworker movements, on the other hand, have hailed the Amnesty policy as a hard won victory. This is a  debate  where notions of morality and decency clash for primacy over justiciable Rights.  The beleagured battleground seems to be the sexworker's identity, her sexuality, her voice and her agency.  

When a whole red-light area is burnt down, what does our conscience say?

On April 15 2008, sex workers' homes in Sitamarhi district in North Bihar were yet again targeted, attacked, and subsequently torched and looted. 12 sex workers and 4 children were brunt alive. Several other sex workers were taken away by the police, some of whom are still missing; several people were booked under the anti-trafficking act. The administration took no interest in protecting the basic citizenship rights of the displaced and victimized sex workers. The camp where the sex workers were housed in the interim did not have food and water, those burnt in the incident did not get access to proper medical care; several people died. Subsequently, after local groups advocated for their return to their dwelling under full administrative protection, the sex workers were allowed to go back to their burnt down homes – but without adequate food and medicine supplies and protection from further harassment. While the local administration is clearly not inclined to make any special...